Sanicki Lawyers Melbourne

  • Home
  • Services
    • Commercial Lawyers Melbourne
    • Music & Entertainment
    • Film & Television
    • Conveyancing Lawyers
    • Trade Marks & Intellectual Property
    • Defamation Lawyers
    • Copyright & Licensing
    • Debt Collection & Insolvency
    • Family Lawyer Melbourne
    • Wills & Estates
    • Franchising Lawyer Melbourne
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • New Technology & Start Ups
    • Fashion & Design
    • Trade Promotions
  • Clients
    • Music & Entertainment
    • Commercial
  • About
  • Careers
    • Work With Us
    • Intern With Us
  • Contact us
+61 3 9510 9888
MADONNA – QUEEN OF POP AND THE COURT ROOM
January 22, 2014
  |  
Moira McKenzie

The link provided below directs readers to an article written by Christie Eliezer on November 2013. It addresses the big win for Madonna and her producer, Robert “Shep” Pettibone, who were caught up in a lawsuit for allegedly sampling a section of music in Madonna’s hit single Vogue.

Salsoul Orchestra sued Madonna for using the strings and horns from their 1977 song Ohh, I Love It (Love Break). They claimed the Queen of Pop illegally sampled their music. Now, for this to be the case, Madonna (and producer) must have taken a substantial section of Salsoul Ochestra’s song without their permission. Note that merely using a small portion of another artist’s song does not necessarily mean a substantial portion has not been used and does not excuse anyone from the consequences of sampling. The test really lies in whether the section of music used goes to the heart of the song, is distinctive, or has that flare that listeners identify with belonging to the original piece of music.

In the United States, and particularly in the District Court of California where Madonna’s case was heard, it was once the standard to find in favour of sampling even for the smallest portion of music used. Luckily for Madonna, the judge in her matter ruled against that standard. The judge adduced that the section of music used in Vogue was “trivial” and unidentifiable by listeners. In fact, so ‘unidentifiable’ was the portion of music in question that it even took Salsoul Orchestra 20 years to find their own instrumental segment “hidden” in the tune of the mega-hit single and commence proceedings.

This raises the issue of whether it matters, in principle, if a listener can easily identify a piece of music as belonging to another artist for it be a viable case of sampling? In essence, has the tree fallen if no one hears it?

The answer to all of the above is yes. Yes, the tree has fallen. Yes, the music has been used without permission, regardless of how much of it has been used and regardless of whether listeners can identify it. The fact of the matter is, no matter how “trivial” the portion of music used might be, should that portion have been used to create a new successful song … say one that has sold over 6 million singles and belonged to a certain pop priestess… the original copyright owner should have the legal right to seek a proportion of the profit made from the exuberant success of the subsequent song.

Granted it only took a mere 20 years to commence proceedings, however (putting aside any questions as to limitation periods) it is justifiable for SalSoul Orchestra to have fought for what they believed rightfully contributed to a pop classic. The law, as demonstrated by this case, often raises many opinion based issues. As such, it can be difficult to assess whether a judge’s ruling is just. Essentially, readers’ opinions about this matter may be likened to their views about the fallen tree.

Thanks to Talla Ansari for this article.

http://www.themusicnetwork.com/madonna-producer-win-vogue-sampling-lawsuit/

Back to news
 
  • Melbourne
    Level 2, 240 Chapel Street
    Prahran, VIC 3181
    Phone +61 3 9510 9888
  • Brisbane
    139 Gotha Street
    Fortitude Valley, QLD 4006
    Phone +61 7 3333 1844
  • General Enquiries
    hello@sanickilawyers.com.au
    Fax +61 3 9510 9888
Sanicki Lawyers Melbourne

Services

  • Commercial Lawyers Melbourne
  • Wills & Estates
  • Music & Entertainment
  • Franchising Lawyer Melbourne
  • Conveyancing Lawyers
  • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
  • Trade Promotions
  • New Technology & Start Ups
  • Defamation Lawyers
  • Fashion & Design
  • Copyright and Licensing
  • Trade Marks & Intellectual Property
  • Film & Television
  • Debt Collection & Insolvency
  • Family Lawyer Melbourne

Info

  • About Us
  • Clients
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Blog

Social

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin

© Copyright 2020. Website & SEO Melbourne & Digital Marketing Melbourne by ZIB Digital | All Rights Reserved.